Oil and Gas Pollution in Vaca Muerta
Forensic Architecture
Oil and Gas Pollution in Vaca Muerta
Date of Incident
02 Jan 2013 – Ongoing
Location
Vaca Muerta, Argentina
Publication Date
14 Oct 2019
In Partnership With
The Guardian
Additional Funding
The Guardian
Forums
Media

Vaca Muerta, Argentina, is one of the world’s largest deposits of shale oil and gas. It is also home to indigenous communities, part of the Mapuche people who live between Chile and Argentina.

Argentinian companies have operated in the region for decades. In 2013 however, an agreement saw the US energy giant Chevron enter Vaca Muerta, in a move which opened up the region for the first time to the international oil and gas industry. Chevron was soon followed by Shell, Total, ExxonMobil, and others.

In collaboration with the Guardian, as part of their series ‘The Polluters’ , we investigated a local Mapuche community’s claim that the oil and gas industry has irreversibly damaged their ancestral homeland, and eroded their traditional ways of life.

Our research was organised around 3 objects: a community building belonging to the local Mapuche community, an oil waste treatment facility that is the subject of an ongoing lawsuit, and an extraction platform which was the site of a major oil spill.

The community building

Play Video

In 2013, the local Mapuche community built this building, from which to monitor the expansion of industry in their lands. The building was soon burnt down, in an intentional fire. Our investigation of the community centre was developed in collaboration with a local activist group, O11CE, and in conversation with the local Mapuche community and their regional confederation, Argentinian anthropologist Jorgelina Villarreal, and an industry monitoring NGO, Observatorio Petrolero Sur.

The treatment facility

Play Video

In August 2018, the Mapuche Confederation of Neuquén filed a lawsuit against the US oil waste management company Treater, alleging that the conditions at a site in Vaca Muerta breached a number of environmental regulations. The lawsuit lists a number of international companies, which it alleges share the blame for environmental damage caused by the facility. Those companies include Shell, Total, ExxonMobil, and a subsidiary of BP, Pan-American Energy. The lawsuit relies on video material captured by workers at the site, as well as material gathered by Greenpeace.

The La Caverna oil spill

Play Video

The La Caverna extraction site, operated jointly by Argentina’s state-run oil company YPF, and US oil services provider Schlumberger, was the site of a major oil spill in August 2018. We investigated using video material shared on social media by workers at the site, and local activists, as well as news footage and satellite images.

NDVI analysis

NDVI 2013-19 - Two side-by-side Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) analyses show densities of vegetation in the region around Añelo, Vaca Muerta, in 2013 and 2019. (Forensic Architecture)
Two side-by-side Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) analyses show densities of vegetation in the region around Añelo, Vaca Muerta, in 2013 and 2019. (Forensic Architecture)

Above, these remote sensing analyses use a technique called Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) to analyse the vegetation cover in the region. Yellow indicates areas that are cleared of vegetation, including oil platforms, the network of roads that connect them, as well as the city of Añelo.

The image below shows the relative difference in vegetation between 2013 and 2019. In yellow, areas of ‘distressed vegetation’ are visible along the Neuquén River, as well as throughout the plateau region whose ownership is disputed between the local Mapuche community and the companies YPF and Chevron.

NDVI Difference 2013-2019 - Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) analysis of the region surrounding the town of Añelo, in Vaca Muerta. (Forensic Architecture)
Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) analysis of the region surrounding the town of Añelo, in Vaca Muerta. (Forensic Architecture)
Forensic Architecture Team
Principal Investigator
Researcher-in-Charge
Research
Voice over
Extended Team
Anthropologist
Remote Sensing
Collaborators
Comunidad Mapuce Campo Maripe
Exhibitions
07 Oct 2022 – 08 Jan 2023
Cloud Studies at Tensta Konsthall
Stiftelsen Tensta Konsthall, Stockholm, Sweden
02 Jul – 17 Oct 2021
Cloud Studies at the Whitworth
The Whitworth, Manchester, United Kingdom
20 Apr – 17 Jul 2021
Agitation Co-op
Temple Bar Gallery + Studios, Dublin, Ireland
23 Oct 2020 – 03 Jan 2021
Antibodies
Palais de Tokyo, Paris
22 Sep – 13 Nov 2020
Cloud Studies at UTS Gallery
UTS Gallery, Sydney
Events
24 Nov 2022
FIDOCS: Forensic Architecture
Centro de Cine y Creación
20 Apr – 17 Jul 2021
Agitation Co-op
Temple Bar Gallery + Studios, Dublin, Ireland
23 Oct 2020 – 03 Jan 2021
Antibodies
Palais de Tokyo, Paris
22 Sep – 13 Nov 2020
Cloud Studies at UTS Gallery
UTS Gallery, Sydney
Press
22 Oct 2019
The Guardian
UK to use finance meant for green energy to support fracking in Argentina
14 Oct 2019
The Guardian
Indigenous Mapuche Pay High Price for Argentina's Fracking Dream
Related Investigations
Destruction and Return in al-Araqib
al-Araqib, Negev/Naqab desert · 01 Jan 2010 – Ongoing
Cloud Studies
Worldwide · 2008 - Ongoing
Gold Mining and Violence in the Amazon Rainforest
Yanomami Territory · 2019 – Ongoing