Pushbacks Across the Evros/Meriç River: Analysis of video evidence
Forensic Architecture
Pushbacks Across the Evros/Meriç River: Analysis of video evidence
Date of Incident
17 Sep 2019
Location
Evros/Meriç river, Greece/Turkey border
Publication Date
13 Dec 2019
In Partnership With
Der Spiegel, HumanRights360
Additional Funding
Open Society Foundations (OSF)
Collaborators
Der Spiegel, HumanRights360
Forums
Legal Process, Media

This investigation is part of a broader project on cases of pushbacks across the Evros/Meriç river. Other investigations include:

‘Pushbacks Across the Evros/Meriç River: The case of Ayşe Erdoğan’

In December 2019, Der Spiegel received a series of videos filmed on a Turkish Border Guard’s mobile phone and on a surveillance camera installed on the Turkish banks of the Evros/Meriç river. These rare videos document a pushback operation as it unfolds for the first time. We were commissioned to analyse the footage and to investigate its veracity. Through our analysis we were able to accurately geolocate and timestamp the footage, and to demonstrate that it indeed captures a pushback operation from the Greek to the Turkish banks, a few hundred metres away from a Greek military watchtower.

Watchtower near the Location, 2019 - Satellite photo showing a Greek military watchtower in close proximity to the location of the pushback, 22 April 2019. (Image courtesy of Google Earth)
Satellite photo showing a Greek military watchtower in close proximity to the location of the pushback, 22 April 2019. (Image courtesy of Google Earth)

These videos corroborate several testimonies of migrants crossing the Evros/Meriç river from Turkey to Greece, who have testified to being detained, beaten, and ‘pushed back’ across the river to Turkey, by unidentified masked men and in full secrecy, without being granted access to asylum procedures. Pushbacks, as this practice is called, contravenes a series of European and international laws. The Greek and EU authorities systematically deny any wrongdoing and refuse to investigate these reports.

White Car at the Location, 16 March 2019 - A white car similar to the one used in the pushback depicted in a satellite photo of the same location, 16 March 2019. (Image courtesy of Google Earth)
A white car similar to the one used in the pushback depicted in a satellite photo of the same location, 16 March 2019. (Image courtesy of Google Earth)
Inflatable Boats in Neo Cheimonio, 2015 - Inflatable boats similar to the one used in the pushback depicted in satellite photos of Neo Cheimonio Police Station, 28 August 2015. (Image courtesy of Google Earth)
Inflatable boats similar to the one used in the pushback depicted in satellite photos of Neo Cheimonio Police Station, 28 August 2015. (Image courtesy of Google Earth)
White Car at the Location, 30 March 2019 - A white car similar to the one used in the pushback depicted in a satellite photo of the same location, 30 March 2019. (Image courtesy of Google Earth)
A white car similar to the one used in the pushback depicted in a satellite photo of the same location, 30 March 2019. (Image courtesy of Google Earth)
Inflatable Boats in Tychero, 2015 - Inflatable boats similar to the one used in the pushback depicted in satellite photos of Tychero Police Station, 28 August 2015. (Image courtesy of Google Earth)
Inflatable boats similar to the one used in the pushback depicted in satellite photos of Tychero Police Station, 28 August 2015. (Image courtesy of Google Earth)

The Evros/Meriç river delineates the only ‘land’ border between Greece and Turkey. Spanning from the Trilateral border with Bulgaria in the North, where the river is called Maritsa, to the Aegean Sea in the South, this so-called ‘natural’ border has, in recent years, been incorporated into a broader ecosystem of border defence. Its riverine characteristics have been weaponised to deter and kill migrants attempting to cross it.

For independent researchers, the militarisation of this border region makes access extremely difficult. A ‘buffer zone’ restricting civilian access to the border runs alongside both banks of the river. Detention centres and border guard stations are often located within this buffer zone, keeping detainees out of sight and without access to legal help.

Witnesses describe having their phones, documents and possessions confiscated, and often thrown into the river, suggesting an operation carefully designed to obscure all possible evidence of human rights violations.

The results of this investigation have been submitted to the State Prosecutor of Orestiada, Evros, the State Prosecutor of Thrace, and the Greek Ombudsman.

Updates

Update — 13 December 2019

The Greek Union of Border Guards responded to our investigation:

‘It is noteworthy how a media organization collaborates with a university department abroad to verify the authenticity of the footage, and yet fails to ask how all the ‘evidence’ captured in the video does not correspond to ‘pushback’ operations. In broad daylight, cameras that happened to be there, conveniently showing a Turkish armed border guard who allows the migrants to disembark. Also ‘accidentally’ the migrants remain calm throughout, disembark in an orderly fashion, they even know where to sit. The article didn’t ask any of these questions but only asked to verify if the footage is original.’

Update — 14 December 2019

The European Commission asked for a thorough investigation.

Update — 15 December 2019

The Greek Prime Minister commented on the video:

‘From the material it does not arise that Hellenic Republic personnel was involved. In some cases conflicted evidence and dates are presented. In any case we are willing to investigate any isolated incident of alleged human rights violations regarding the issue of migration management.’

Forensic Architecture Team
Researcher in Charge
Project Coordinator
Research & Video Investigation
Research Assistance
Research Supervision
Project Support
Collaborators
Exhibitions
24 Apr – 10 Oct 2021
This World is White No Longer: Views of a Decentered World
Museum der Moderne, Salzburg, Austria
Events
24 Apr – 10 Oct 2021
This World is White No Longer: Views of a Decentered World
Museum der Moderne, Salzburg, Austria
Press
14 Dec 2019
Spiegel
EU-Kommission setzt griechische Behörden unter Druck
13 Dec 2019
Spiegel
Videos Show Apparent Illegal Pushback of Migrants
Related Investigations
Pushbacks Across the Evros/Meriç River: The case of Ayşe Erdoğan
Evros/Meriç river, Greece/Turkey · 04 May 2019 – 05 May 2019
Privatised Push-Back of the Nivin
Central Mediterranean · 01 Nov 2018
Sea Watch vs the Libyan Coastguard
Mediterranean Sea · 06 Nov 2017
The Seizure of the Iuventa
Mediterranean Sea · 02 Aug 2017
Death By Rescue: The lethal effects of non-assistance at sea
Mediterranean Sea · 12 Apr 2015 – 18 Apr 2015
The Left-to-Die Boat
Mediterranean Sea · 27 Mar 2011 – 10 Apr 2011
Herbicidal Warfare in Gaza
Khan Younes, Gaza, Occupied Palestinian Territories · 01 Jan 2014 – Ongoing
Shipwreck at the Threshold of Europe, Lesvos, Aegean Sea
Aegean Sea, Lesvos · 28 Oct 2015
The Killing of Muhammad Gulzar
Kastanies/Pazarkule border crossing, Evros/Meriç region · 04 Mar 2020
The Killing of Muhammad al-Arab
Evros/Meriç river delta · 02 Mar 2020
Pushbacks Across the Evros/Meriç River: Situated Testimony
Evros/Meriç river, Greek-Turkish border · 01 Oct 2016
Pushbacks Across the Evros/Meriç River: The Case of Parvin
Evros/Meriç river, Greek-Turkish border · 01 Feb 2020
Drift-backs in the Aegean Sea
Aegean Sea · March 2020 – Ongoing
Fire in Moria Refugee Camp
Lesvos, Greece · 08 Sep 2020
The Evros/Meriç River: A Century of Border Design
Evros/Meriç river, Greece/Turkey · 1926 – 2025